When it comes to dating and relationships, everyone has an opinion. And who better than your favorite web stars to tell it like it is? Meet E! Online’s “Answer Bitch” Leslie Gornstein, “Internet quasi-celebrity/fascist” Jason Mulgrew, TV and Internet talk show host The Resident and famed videoblogger Amanda Congdon, and hear what they have to say.

I’m seeing a man who recently revealed to me that he’s slept with over 100 women and he’s only 30! He says he used to be a “playboy” but that those days are over now. We’ve had fun with each other and I would like to keep seeing him, but I can’t help questioning his character—I mean, was he sleeping with anything that walked before?! Is there a way for me to look past this guy’s past? Should sexual history really matter in the first place?